Does the iPhone 3GS Do It All?

Posted on 20 Jun 2009 by Joe Tomasone

image

 

I was reading a thread in which the poster opined that the iPhone 3GS finally solves all the issues that he had with his v1 iPhone.   That got me thinking: With all the great improvements between the new hardware and the new OS 3.0, did Apple truly fix every issue I have had with the iPhone?   After some sober thought, I ‘ve concluded that it hasn ‘t quite fixed everything just yet.   Here ‘s what I ‘d still like to see:

1. Home Screen Management:  There ‘s still no way to organize your home screens short of sliding applications all over creation.  New applications go in the first available spot instead of being able to be categorized.   With as many apps as I have, I like similar-purposed apps (travel, shopping, media, games, etc) to be on the same page(s), and the pages I use the most towards the front.   

2. Ability To Save/Edit Documents:  Even with Docs To Go debuting, you still cannot receive an email with a document and edit it on the iPhone “ you still must have a computer act as the middleman.   While you can view a document (which I will admit is the most needed function), you still cannot save it somewhere (say in a ‘Documents ‘ app) to review later.   You could simply save the email, but this adds substantially to the mail space quota that many organizations have.   You could save it to Air Share, Discover, or any similar app, but again the computer must be the middleman.   Imagine if you could hold down on a document link in an email and have a ‘Save to Documents ‘ item pop up.  Bliss.

3. Remove Stock Apps: I don ‘t track stocks.  I use weather apps with a lot more capability than the Weather app.   Who needs the Contacts app when there ‘s a contacts tab in the Phone app?   Don ‘t need ‘em, don ‘t want ‘em, but I can ‘t get rid of them, except by banishing them to the last screen.  Yes, I know, I could jailbreak and handle this a few different ways, but this is about what Apple needs to do “ not what I could do.

4. Background Apps: OK, I ‘ll say it “ some apps should run in the background “ or at least be able to act on external events.  IRC clients, IM clients, maybe a weather alert app “ all examples of perfectly legitimate needs for apps to be able to work in the background.  Now while I understand Apple ‘s point that having apps slinging traffic around all day will have a potentially devastating toll on battery life, a balance needs to be reached.  Apple ‘s own Phone and Mail apps run in the background “ but the data usage is both limited by the app and managed by the user.   Surely something besides background notifications (which as far as I can tell really have nothing to do with background processing at all “ they are little more than glorified text messages coming in) can be worked out.   For example, an IM client, upon receiving an incoming IM, wakes up and notifies the user.  Or perhaps a weather app plays an alarm sound and displays a message about a tornado warning.    These are things that are do-able, just not done.

5.  Disable Landscape Mode: Sometimes it ‘s ME that ‘s in landscape mode, not the iPhone.   I sometimes like to read news or surf the web while lying on my side in bed “ but the iPhone is determined to keep everything oriented up.   So we play this game, tilting the iPhone just enough to keep it from rotating.   Why can ‘t we temporarily disable it when needed?

6. SMS Sounds: We can configure sounds for just about everything else “ why can ‘t we choose a custom-made sound for an SMS alert? 

7. Voicemail Through WiFi: As of now, your visual voicemail can only be obtained through the cellular network.   This can be a problem if you are roaming and have data roaming off or simply have no cell signal (say at work or at your vacation house, etc), as you will get no voicemail and no voicemail alerts until you enable data or reconnect to the cell network.   If you are overseas (say on a business trip), enabling roaming data to get your voicemails can be very expensive.  On my last trip to Europe, 3 voicemails cost me over $40 in data costs!   Given AT&T ‘s desire to keep as much data off the network to enhance overall performance, this is one change that should be a win-win for all.   Well, unless you ‘re counting on that overseas revenue.

8. VCF, ICS Support: You simply can ‘t do anything with an emailed contact or calendar entry unless the email account is an Exchange account.   I haven ‘t checked in 3.0, but under 2.0 you couldn ‘t use them from the Web either.   This is shortsighted.   What makes it bizarre is that you can send a contact as a VCF even though you cannot receive them as such.

9. Headphones: Just because I plug in headphones does not mean that I want the iPod to immediately play.  Really.  Make it configurable.

10. Video Searching: The drag bar is nice, but imprecise.  I often have to re-watch a segment to get back to where I was interrupted.  

11. Monthly Calendar Entries: We still cannot add a calendar entry for something that occurs on the 3rd Thursday (or 2nd Tuesday, etc) of each month.

12. Future Calendar Entries: You just received an invitation to a wedding on September 14th, 2010.   Hope your tapping finger is limbered up, you ‘ll be there a while getting that month up so that you can add the entry.

There ‘s probably a few more items that I could add to this list “ and probably more that someone else might that don ‘t bother me enough to have noticed.    How about you?   What would you change in iPhone 4.0?

Share this:
Share this page via Email Share this page via Digg this Share this page via Facebook Share this page via Twitter

10 Responses to Does the iPhone 3GS Do It All?

  1. Rick says:

    Your #1 is my #1 – would love to have iTunes be able to show my screens, or at least have a category listing for the Apps screen to place them properly on the phone.

  2. patrickj says:

    Great list Joe – I especially feel your pain on Numbers 1-4, and like Rick, I absolutely agree on Number 1.

  3. Philipp says:

    "Headphones: Just because I plug in headphones does not mean that I want the iPod to immediately play. Really. Make it configurable."

    It doesn't to that when I plug in my headphones
    —–
    "Future Calendar Entries"
    Just press and hold the arrow key in the Calendar for skipping to the next month

  4. mcj4476 says:

    How about built-in WiFi or Bluetooth syncing to iTunes or at least better management of Podcasts on the phone so that you can detect and download new episodes?

  5. Bay area dude says:

    I agree. One reason I like the phone is I can read email while lying in bed. But now the auto-landscape mode kicks in when I'm reading mail while lying down. This sucks that Apple can't make a simple toggle setting allowing you to turn the auto-landscape on or off. I plan to get a gphone in the next couple years.

  6. Seven says:

    12 – you can't get it unlocked just like any other phone. I didn't get the new one as I still depend on this phone specially on traveling.

    13 – battery is not removable.

    Calander reminders has been fixed though, you could view and save any apointment.

  7. #5. Happens to me all the time. I'll be lying in bed, and as soon as i launch Safari it flips on me. It would be awesome to have a toggle to disable this if you wanted. Which is exactly what you can do on a JB phone. Yet Apple has not made one. =/

  8. Andrei says:

    #5 definitely! And it's stupid coz it's not rocket science to enable users to do that.

  9. aliciab says:

    Thx for the post. I'm also for

    disable landscape sometimes
    custom sms sound

    and of course a way to organize apps :-)

  10. Kev says:

    The video slider is now as precise as it can be – you can move your finger up and down to change speed, down to individual seconds.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

*

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>